Skip to main content


At Sholley Insurance Agency, we exceed expectations.

A culture of doing the right things.

Home » About Our Agency » Testimonials

Anyone can promise great service, but not everyone can deliver it. At the Sholley Insurance Agency, we’ve built a culture around doing the right things. But don’t just take our word for it. Read these client testimonials to see exactly what we mean.

You go so above and beyond for us every day, I am constantly singing your praises. Kassy could not believe the level of service that was provided. She wanted me to thank you for taking care of this so quickly for her! Honestly, thank you for everything! I am so grateful to work with such an amazing team!

Heidi WesleyLighting New York

The Sholley Agency always exceeds my expectations! Pattie is an expert at handling claims and billing issues and has saved our employees thousands of dollars by working with the insurance companies and facilities to make sure claims are processed correctly.

They promptly and efficiently answer all our insurance questions and provide exceptionally friendly service. They always work diligently to get us the best possible price and the plan designs that fit our needs. I have never had an agency provide better service and support.

Carrie PardoeHR Manager, Icon Legacy Custom Modular Homes LLC

I really appreciate the service you provide for us! Thumbs up!

Scott BordnerNRG Controls North, Inc.

I wanted to reach out and say thanks to your agency. You guys do a great job for Grandview. I really appreciate the efforts you guys give us. Huge applause for both Shawn and Pattie. They are really great to work with. Thanks for standing behind our employees!

Bill MettlerChief Financial Officer, Grandview Nursing & Rehabilitation

I can attest to one thing, anyone that is looking for a reputable insurance agency, I will highly recommend they contact you. Anything I’ve ever needed help with, Sholley Insurance Agency has gone over and above getting the help and/or answers I’ve needed.

Melissa BilgerKeller Marine & RV

Thank you for your efforts with regard to this claim issue. You went above and beyond your obligation. I feel confident in saying that no other insurance broker would do all that you have done.

Barbara BonsallHR Administrator, Superior Walls by Advanced Concrete Systems, Inc.

On behalf of Pik Rite employees, thank you for all of the energy you put into guiding us to make well-informed, cost-saving decisions for high-quality treatment.

Janice L. ShivelyOffice Manager, Pik Rite Inc.

The employee benefits team at the Sholley Agency is very knowledgeable and detail-oriented. They have been very proactive in helping us find a plan designed to meet our needs. I feel like I have a partner helping to navigate through the constantly changing regulations. They are a pleasure to work with!

Gail Erickson

Lynn Sholley and his team have always gone above and beyond to assist our company with all of our needs. He treats everyone like family...we couldn't ask for a better insurance agent!

Dean Koch

Professional, timely, and most importantly, the Sholley Agency has absolutely the best customer service, hands down.

Ryan FritzRS Fritz Trucking

The Sholley Agency has always been very responsive to my requests. I would and do recommend the Sholley Agency to anyone I speak to who is looking for insurance options. I love the fact that the Sholley Agency is a broker and not fixed to one particular insurance company. I shop every renewal period.

Trace Nevil

The Sholley Agency (Lynn) has helped us out in the past, in getting quotes to us for projects that have specialty insurance coverage, with our audits (to understand them and go to bat for us, if there is a problem), and various other insurance matters. We have been insured through The Sholley Agency for over 30 years and, needless to say, are very pleased with their service.

Patty WilliamsLycoming Supply Inc.

Michelle was extremely helpful in getting my renters insurance policy set up with a very short deadline. Moving can be a stressful time, but Michelle worked to make this part of the transition very smooth and stress-free! She answered my questions and offered suggestions on which policy would be the best fit for me. I would highly recommend Michelle to my friends and family.

Olivia Miller

Bruce reached out to us with options of a large amount of annual savings. He was very prompt in getting us all the necessary paperwork to review and sign for timely activation.

Christopher Laukaitis

Lynn is extremely responsive to our business needs and is always willing to provide his assistance. We completely trust and highly recommend Lynn Sholley and the Sholley Agency.

Joe SchmadelSun Precast Company, Inc.

Very helpful Great rates very friendly easy smooth process. I loved the experience I had, so helpful.

Sarah Wagman

Ethan was quick to get back to me, explained the policy to me that I was looking for, took care of what type of coverage I needed.

Jim Snyder

Ethan was personable, efficient, professional, and kind. He went out of his way to secure commercial insurance for us to meet a short deadline. Wonderful customer service experience!

Terri HixsonTransport, LLC

Excellent service! I’m always able to get the information I need. Michelle took the time to review our policies to get us the coverage we need for the best price.

Gary Printzenhoff

Extremely knowledgeable, very helpful, and great customer service.

Justin Witmer

Chris and the Sholley team offer the best service and are always willing to help.

Nate LawrenceUnited Plate Glass Co.

Pam helped us establish a new policy with very short notice. She was accommodating and very kind. We are so grateful for her expertise!

Anthony and Candice Stasheski

I love working with Chris, Pattie, and Shawn. I have been working with insurance agencies for almost 20 years now and I have never had the service that I do from your agency. They are wonderful to work with and they always answer my questions quickly.

Carrie HammondIcon Legacy custom Modular Homes
About Our Agency - Landscape View of Trees and Sky Along With Sholley Agency Main Office Building

Get Started Today

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

Get a Quote
  Google Reviews

  Request an Insurance Quote

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get a Quote

It only takes a minute to get started.

  • Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
  • Go over your options with an agent.
  • Get the coverage you need.

Would you rather discuss this in person? Get in touch with an agent today!