Sholley Insurance Agency provides insurance solutions to protect what you love.
A relationship built on trust and focused on your needs.
Home »
Your family, your business, and your lifestyle are vital to you, but identifying the best way to protect them can be difficult. Since 1985, the Sholley Insurance Agency has helped people protect what they love. Because we live in the same communities as you do, we understand how to best help you find the right insurance solutions to meet your unique needs.
For over three decades, our family and dedicated employees have proudly served Central Pennsylvanians as their local, independent insurance agency. We are an independent agency staffed with local insurance agents—people who live and work where you do. We’re here to work for you. We will provide you with the best products to meet your insurance needs. The Sholley Insurance Agency is committed to helping protect what you love and value most.
35 Years in Business
50+ Insurance Partners
Our Mission Statement
At the Sholley Insurance Agency, we view every situation as unique and deserving of an expertly customized plan. As your trusted advisor, we work to the highest standards of excellence to ensure you get the service and solutions you deserve.
Get Started Today
As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.
Get a Quote
Why Choose the Sholley Insurance Agency?
We strive to do our best by our community and clients. Here’s how.
- We are staffed with local insurance agents—people who live and work where you do.
- We’re here to work for you and will provide the best products and service to meet your insurance needs.
We are local
We’re your neighbors and share your interest in the local communities we live in and serve, as well as understanding the area to better serve you.
We are experts
We clarify the complexities of insurance, helping you make smart decisions. We not only find you competitive pricing but also make sure you are adequately covered.
We are your advocate
We will save you time by assisting in every aspect of the insurance process, working with the insurance company on your behalf.
We offer creative solutions
We recognize the unique circumstances of each client and work with you to develop a strategy that best meets your needs while being mindful of your budget.
We offer one-stop shopping
We represent multiple insurance companies and offer business, benefits, and personal insurance to find the best solutions for all your insurance needs.
We give you a choice
We compare different companies, products, and policies to get you the right blend of price, coverage, and service.
We save you money
We can bundle your policies for premium savings, and tailor coverage to meet your specific insurance needs and budget.
We are lifetime consultants
We periodically review your coverage and help you through all the changes in life and business by enhancing your solutions to match those changes.
We are service-oriented
We will be there for you every step of the way with a personalized, local touch to make a positive impact.
Award-Winning Agency
We are proud to be recognized for the work we do for our clients and community.
- Achieved the Leadership Circle designation from Grange Insurance.
- Recognized as one of the highest performing independent agency partners (business development and customer service).
Visit us at one of our three locations.
We are proud to serve clients throughout Central Pennsylvania, including Williamsport, PA, Mifflinburg, PA, Middleburg, PA, Northumberland, PA, Sunbury, PA, and beyond.
Agency
Affiliations
We’ve built strong ties to the most reputable and trusted organizations to stay on the cutting-edge of the industry and provide you with the best information and products to help you achieve your goals.
Community
Membership
Giving back and being active in our community is always a priority for our agency. We support and get involved in local charities to make a difference in our community, and are members of organizations to further develop change.
Request an Insurance Quote
As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.
Get a Quote
It only takes a minute to get started.
- Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
- Go over your options with an agent.
- Get the coverage you need.
